Posted by: emkamm93 | September 24, 2014

Knowing When You Look

LewisWe spent a long time dissecting this photo of Lewis Payne, taken shortly before his execution for the attempted assassination of the Secretary of State, in class a few weeks back.

Our discussion ranged from “omg he’s such a lil’ cutie” to “look at how the light separates his face, could that speak to the division between life and death in the moment of this photograph?”

I had never seen it before, and processing the photo organically with my classmates was an enriching experience. When we were asked if our view of the photo changed at all when we discovered why it was taken, I really had to say “no.” This man had attempted to commit a crime, and although he was handsome, he would be dead by now anyway….and I really needed to get a hold on myself. Nonetheless, this captured moment, one of his last, was still rather chilling.

Yet although the photo was kind of creepy, we still felt comfortable cracking jokes about his model-looks, hence my creation of the following photos:

Lewis Payne

The day after class, I found this image of young Istvan Reiner as I scrolled through Tumblr (I’m linking to the photo, as opposed to posting it, as I am unsure about the copyrights).

“Aw, what a cute little kid,” I thought, scrolling further down to read the tags, but there weren’t any.

I searched Google for the image, and pulled up multiple Twitter and Pinterest accounts which all had the same shocking assertion: that the photo was taken in the days before the little boy’s untimely death. I knew this couldn’t be true, but when I looked closer, what I assumed were pajamas could actually be prison clothes.

Yet I still didn’t want to take social media posts as a real source, so I kept looking, still hoping that this little boy wasn’t actually murdered in a concentration camp. But when I found the image in the photo archives of the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, that hope was gone, as they said it was “taken shortly before he was killed in Auschwitz” (source).

Knowing the origin of this photo inspired so many more feelings than James’. Although both boys are “cute” it’s in really different ways. When we were told that Lewis was being sent to his death, there was a momentary dip in my feelings, but it didn’t really change the way I looked at him, but for Istvan, it was different.

This child committed no crime. He was innocent. Innocent of both guilt and the knowledge that his death was approaching. It’s the glee in his eyes that makes his photo even more haunting. He doesn’t know.

It’s knowledge, I think, that really separates these two photos:the subject’s own knowledge of their impending death, the viewer knowing the reasons for their subsequent executions.

Both lives were taken too soon, but I think that Istvan’s photo, because of his age and innocence, demands more reverence.

What do you think?


Responses

  1. Your edits of the Lewis Payne photographs are pretty great. He really could have been an Abercrombie model if he wasn’t a criminal born in the wrong century. I agree that looking at the photograph of the little boy and later learning his fate definitely made me feel a pang of sadness which I had not felt for Lewis. Perhaps it’s because the little boy died due to no fault of his own and appears so innocent and carefree in his photograph while Lewis Payne is being punished for a crime of his own doing. The child’s circumstances definitely make me more sympathetic toward him.

  2. I was really interested about the idea of the photo shoot so I did some digging and found some others of him here: http://www.loc.gov/pictures/search/?q=lewis%20payne

    Some of them are fascinating and there are also some illustrations depicting him in that list of images.

  3. Thanks for finding those, Iris. I had a feeling he should also be in a Hollister ad, but ran out of photos : P

    But that’s really interesting, that there are so many pictures of him floating around. It makes me wonder about the intention of the photos — why did they take so many? What were they planning on using them for?

  4. Apparently, Gardner took photographs of all those who participated in the assassination plot, visiting them while they were imprisoned and were awaiting execution. He also documented their executions. I’ve been looking, but can’t find information on WHY Garner took the pictures or what his intention was. Now I’m even more curious.

  5. EmKamm, your photoshop skills are impeccable. As are your insights.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Categories

%d bloggers like this: